Eliot's Eats

A life well read and well fed

,

Esau’s Pottage

Isn’t it funny how you can discover something you have never heard of before only to come across it again and again in the days following.

Recently, I was confronted with Steampunks.   Now I see this movement referenced everywhere—on TV, in literature, on the radio, while shopping for jewelry.

images
A Steampunk

The same is true for Esau’s Soup.   (Sorry, that wasn’t much of a segue.)  My mom got me a couple of unique cookbooks for my birthday, The Renaissance Cookbook (which I think was self-published) and The Old Farmer’s Almanac Colonial Cookbook.   The former is pretty much fluff but the latter has some interesting recipes and history in it.

We were perusing through cookbooks at Christmas (a favorite pastime of mine) and I came across “Esau’s Pottage.”   Of course from Sunday school classes of long ago, I know the story of Esau and Jacob.   I had forgotten about the mention of soup.

We commented on this recipe on Christmas Day.   The next day I took mom to lunch at Laffa, a great Medi-Eastern restaurant in Tulsa.   What was on the menu?   Esau’s Soup.

I had to order it and it was delicious.

Then, I saw two more references to it that same day—one on the internet and one in Whole Foods.

That’s just crazy.

While I was in Whole Foods, I bought the ingredients.

Here is my rendition of Esau’s Pottage, heavily influenced by Laffa’s version.   Their menu states:  “Esau sold his birthright to his brother Jacob in exchange for a bowl of this lentil soup—that’s some pretty expensive soup! If Esau had had them, he too would have added a blend of creamy tomatoes & chickpeas. Don’t worry, we’re charging less than a birthright!”   This Laffa version was worth every penny!

Esau’s Soup
based on “Esau’s Pottage” from The Old Farmer’s Almanac Colonial Cookbook, “Jacob’s Lentil Stew,” and Esau’s Soup from Laffa.

2 T. olive oil
1  large onion, diced
1 clove garlic, minced
2 carrots, sliced
2 celery stalks, sliced
2 c. dry red lentils
1/2 c. pearl barley
2 c. dried garbanzo beans, soaked overnight and drained
2 qts. chicken stock
3 c. crushed tomatoes (like Pomi)
1 c. water
1 1/2 t. ground coriander
1 T. fresh parsley, chopped
1 bay leaf
Salt and pepper to taste

Heat olive oil in a large soup pot.   Add onion and saute until soft.   Add garlic, carrots, and celery and saute about two minutes more.   Add lentils, pearl barley, and garbanzo beans.   Cover with stock.   Add tomatoes, water and seasonings.   Stir to combine.

Bring to a simmer, cover, and let simmer on low heat for 90 minutes to 2 hours.  Set a timer and stir about every 20 minutes.

2013-12-29 13.25.51
Thick and hearty and comforting.

Soup should be thick and hearty and really is more of a “pottage” than a soup.

If it has been awhile since your Sunday school days, here is the reference to lentil soup in from the Old Testament.

23-twins1

Once when Jacob was boiling pottage, Esau came in from the field, and he was famished.
And Esau said to Jacob, “Let me eat some of that red pottage, for I am famished!” (Therefore his name was called Edom.)
Jacob said, “First sell me your birthright.”
Esau said, “I am about to die; of what use is a birthright to me?”
Jacob said, “Swear to me first.” So he swore to him, and sold his birthright to Jacob.
Then Jacob gave Esau bread and pottage of lentils, and he ate and drank, and rose and went his way. Thus Esau despised his birthright.

—-Genesis 25: 29-35 (RSV)

2013-12-29 13.37.28
You may want to garnish with more parsley. I didn’t because it was too cold to make another trip to the green house.

For more history on this soup, please visit The History Kitchen whose recipe influenced me as well.

If you want a more authentic version, here is the recipe that sparked our foray into Old Testament food.  Feel free to grab a shin of beef and make the following:

Easu’s Pottage
From The Old Farmer’s Almanace Colonial Cookbook
“From an old cookbook, here is the lineal descendant of the soup for which Esau sold his birthright—the kind of soup to come home to on a winter’s night.”

1/2 lb. green split peas
1/4 lb.red lentils
2 T. pearl barley
4 T. white beans
1 good soup bone
1/2 pound shin beef
2 carrots, diced
2 stalks celery, diced
1 onion, thinly sliced
2 qts. water
salt and freshly ground pepper
large sprig of parsley
extra parsley to garnish

Put the peas, lentils, barley and beans into a large bowl, cover to twice their depth with cold water and leave to swell overnight.   Next day rinse well.   Put the bone and the meat (in one piece) with salt and water into a soup kettle.  Bring slowly to the boil, skim, then add the other ingredients.   Cover and simmer as slowly as possible for 2 to 3 hours, stirring occasionally.   when the soup is ready the legumes will have dissolved into a puree, and sieving will be unnecessary.   Before serving taste for seasoning, remove the bone, and serve a little of the meat with each serving.   Garnish with scissored parsley.  Serves 6-8.

 

This recipe may be more authentic, but I will stick with my version.  (Luckily this dish freezes well because this recipe makes a lot.)

Esau

Now, where else but my own weird musings could you have read about Steampunks and a Bible tale in the same blog post?  Probably no where.

Comments & Replies

24 responses to “Esau’s Pottage”

  1. Kitchen Kelli Avatar

    YUM! I love the story of Esau – and this pottage is right up my alley – freezable? Yay! I love to take this sort of thing to work each day, especially when it’s cold outside. I must try this. Pinning on my comforting soups and stews board!

    1. Eliot Avatar

      Thanks for pinning it, Kelli. Hope you try it.

  2. chef mimi Avatar

    Great post! Isn’t Laffa fabulous? We had the starter platter the first time there and it was to die for. Great looking pottage, or whatever it’s called!

    1. Eliot Avatar

      Love Laffa!!!!!

  3. Liz Berg Avatar

    I’ve been nursing a batch of lentil soup all week…no one else will touch it, so I’ve been enjoying it for my lunch each day. Never heard of Esau’s pottage…but love the biblical history and the yummy soup!

    1. Eliot Avatar

      Had this for lunch today myself.

  4. kitchenriffs Avatar
    kitchenriffs

    I love soups like this! I use dried legumes and pulses all the time in soup (had one last night, in fact). This version of Esau’s Pottage looks terrific. Good stuff – thanks.

    1. Eliot Avatar

      Pretty hearty stuff!

  5. The Café Sucre Farine Avatar

    It’s so true (and funny) that once you learn about something, it seems to show up everywhere. I’ve definitely had that happen. Such an interesting history for this soup.

    1. Eliot Avatar

      I think there is a name for this phenomenon. Perhaps I will run across the name of it (again and again and again). Lol

  6. Tina Culbertson Avatar

    So true, you couldn’t read about such varied topics all in one post except here! Steampunk confuses me but I don’t think I have looked into it all that well.
    The soup is absolutely perfect.

    1. Eliot Avatar

      Thanks, Tina. It has been good as leftovers for lunch!

  7. sprinklesandsauce Avatar
    sprinklesandsauce

    Wow! Quite a history!

    1. Eliot Avatar

      I hope you check out The History Kitchen for the full scoop.

  8. Culinary Flavors Avatar

    You reminded me of a story that I’ve learned during my school years! I am so glad I’ve seen how this soup looks like! Sometimes all universe pushes us to a certain way, doesn’t it?

    1. Eliot Avatar

      That is true.

  9. Pamela @ Brooklyn Farm Girl Avatar

    I’ve gone to a few Steampunk events and have some friends of friends, they always great shoes! 🙂

    1. Eliot Avatar

      I love some of the jewelry. 🙂

  10. Food Stories (@FoodStoriesBlog) Avatar

    Love your eclectic blog post & the recipe looks wonderful 🙂

    1. Eliot Avatar

      Thanks, C.J.

  11. mjskit Avatar

    A steampunk? Never heard of it and hope to never see one. 🙂 Weird! Have never heard of Esau’s Soup either. What a tasty looking soup! Love the mixture of all of proteins with barley. Thanks for sharing this oldie but goodie.

    1. Eliot Avatar

      I don’t know. I hope I run into one someday. 🙂 Thanks and the soup is really hearty.

  12. Lea Ann Avatar

    That has happened to me this week with Pickle Dip. I guess I’m destined to make it for Superbowl. How fun that you’ve shared this with us along with the story. Great looking soup.

    1. Eliot Avatar

      See…it happens! I don’t think I’ve heard of pickle dip so now I will probably see that everywhere too. 🙂