“Faux” Meyer Lemon Marmalade

With about twenty pounds of Meyer Lemons to use up quickly (some were not in the best shape after the eight hour trip from Houston), I quickly resorted to canning up lots of this bright and sunshiny fruit.  (For all the other ways I used lemons, see my last post here.)

Meyer Lemons from Eliot's Eats

I found two great marmalade recipes, one very simple one and one more traditional.

First, here is the simpler one:

“Faux” Meyer Lemon Marmalade
from Emily Kaiser’s Meyer Lemon Marmalade

3 lbs. Meyer Lemons (About 12 or so according the original recipe.  Mine were so large, I used 5.)
3 cups sugar

Rinse the lemons and pat dry. Zest the lemons using a large peeler/zester.  You want pretty thick strips of the zest, about 1/8 inch thick. Then, cut lemons in half and juice, reserving the juice (about 4 cups).

In a large, heavy saucepan, cover the strips with 8 cups of cold water and bring to a boil; boil for 1 minute. Drain the strips and rinse under cold running water. Blanch two more times; the final time, drain the strips but do not rinse them.

Meyer Lemons from Eliot's Eats

The strips will break apart during the blanching process.


Return the strips to the saucepan. Add the reserved juice and the sugar. Simmer over moderate heat, stirring to dissolve the sugar, then skimming any foam, until the marmalade sets, about 30-40 minutes.

Eliot's Eats

Ladle the marmalade into 5-6 hot 1/2-pint canning jars, leaving 1/4 inch of space at the top.   Add lids and screw on rings. Process in water bath for 15 minutes.  Remove and let stand at room temperature for 2 days before serving.

For some reason, this “faux” marm turned dark and almost honey looking.

Meyer Lemon  Marm from Eliot's Eats

My more traditional marmalade (made from this recipe), was bright and sunshiny.

Meyer Lemon Marmalade from Eliot's Eats

We did taste tests and sent a couple of samples to the in-laws in Houston (from whence all the lemons came).  So far, none of us can decide which is our favorite, the faux or the traditional.

Meyer lemons are in season this month so seek out some and make some marm!

15 comments to “Faux” Meyer Lemon Marmalade

  • I’d eat either of these, but I’m curious about the ‘faux’ moniker. Maybe I’m just not a marmalade expert, but it seems real enough to me.

  • Oh Debra, you lucky girl! I just visited your other post too. That Lemony Brown Sugar Syrup sounds awesome! My oh my, your house must have smelled like lemon heaven while you were making all those goodies. I’ve never had the desire to make any kind of marmalade but you make it sound fairly easy. I would love to preserve the goodness of Meyers some how. I’ve thought of making Lemon Pickle but just haven’t been able to bring myself to doing it. Perhaps one day, I’ll try my hand at marmalade!

    Thanks so much for sharing, Debra…I have a feeling you’ll be sharing lots of yummy Meyer recipes!!!

  • Angie@Angie's Recipes

    20 pounds of lemon!! Lucky you, Debra. I love both colours, but I wonder why it turned honey coloured…

  • Lemon may even edge out chocolate as a favorite flavor for me. I know, I know……chocolate usually rules but wow, I’m a lemon lover. Homemade marmalade sounds like heaven. Why can’t I live next door to you?!

  • I crave lemon. I eat very little jam, but make an exception with marmalade. Together??? Oh my! Oh my! Ice cream topping. On pork chops. Chicken.
    Filling for sweet rolls. We haven’t even come to toast, biscuits and muffins.

  • I’m not sure why you call it faux – any gelled substance made with citrus is marmalade – right? Maybe it is non-traditional like mine…………both of them sure look delicious!

    • You’re making me do a google search, Kelli. 🙂 I called it faux because you don’t have to soak the lemon sections and this recipe just has the zest. But, I am checking the true definition now..LOL

  • mae

    That recipe sounds fantastic. If only you could share all those Meyer Lemons with the rest of us, we would probably make some too. But they are kind of scarce & expensive if you don’t have a tree of your own!

    best… mae at maefood.blogspot.com

  • mjskit

    You lucky girl!!! Need to find me some Meyer Lemons! This looks great!